Legends Diner open

Josh Linehan/Brookings Beacon Mike and Sheana Siegel are the proprietors of Legends Diner & Sweeterie, now serving lunch on Kasan Ave. in Volga.

By Josh Linehan

The Brookings Beacon

VOLGA — The old grocery store on the main drag in Volga is back open for business — this time as a diner.

Brought to you by stalwarts of the local food scene — Mike and Sheana Siegel of Midwest Fresh Catering and food truck — Legends Diner & Sweeterie at 227 Kasan Ave. in Volga is now open weekdays for lunch and looking to staff up and offer full diner hours soon.

The look of the place — call it retro-modern, with classic diner features like a checkerboard floor and low banquette seating, but with the ‘legends’ updated through the 80s and 90s pop culture of the owners’ youth — is so transformed from its history that those who remember it as Jager’s Grocery or Lyle’s Foodland would be well served to stop in just to see the building.

“The initial feedback has been great,” Mike Siegel said. “People love to come in just to look around. Sheana has done all the brainstorming and design, mainly. She’s had some help from Billy Designs, which is kind of like conceptualizing how busy we can get the walls. But basically, everything that’s up here, she just said, ‘Put this here,’ and I said, OK.”

For the Siegels, who met working at Country Kitchen in the 1990s, it’s a dream come true to own a brick and mortar restaurant in their hometown.

“Since we’ve been a couple, we’ve always wanted to open our own brick and mortar, and we were uncertain as to where exactly that would be, but we knew we wanted to be in Volga,” Mike Siegel said. “Our three kids have all gone to school here. I went to school here. My sibling went to school here, and Sheana taught here as a Spanish teacher and then also as a teacher’s aide. So we have a lot of ties to the community.”

For now, Legends is open for lunch weekdays serving a funky mix of both Midwestern — hot beef commercial — and East Coast — Disco fries — diner favorites.

There’s also a pair of bakery cases featuring desserts, sweets, Sheana’s cheesecakes and Mike’s fresh sourdough bread.

The Siegels bought the building a while back and did the renovations themselves while also running Midwest Fresh. The original plan was to open the restaurant and run both full time at once, but some staffing challenges led to the scaled back opening of the diner while they continue to cater full time.

“The backstory would be: We’re pretty blue collar. We don’t have a lot of money, and so we saved up enough money to buy the building, and then we’ve had help from some contractors, obviously plumbing and electrical. But most of the build out, or I would say a lot of the build out, I’ve done myself. Gross Construction came in, helped frame some walls, hung up drywall, stuff like that. But the tile on the floor, booths in here, all the painting,” Mike Siegel said.

“There’s been a huge amount of work that went into the place, a lot of sweat equity, and, in the politest way possible, we just hate debt,” he said. “So we took the long way, and we’re really happy with the way it’s turned out. Everything seems to be working pretty good. Got some equipment that needs to be fidgeted with a little bit here and there, but customers have been really excited about the food.”

And that goes for the clientele, as well.

“I think things are going as good as we have a right to expect. We’ve got a lot of moving parts in our business right now, and so starting off slow and manageable here. Ideally, we just open it up and let it buck and roar. But this seems to be working out.”

When it’s fully up and humming, the Legends location will feature two full working kitchens so the Siegels can cater and run the diner from one location. And the food at the diner will follow from the catering menu — a lot of classic favorites with bold flavors.

“I would call it a fast food restaurant, but really — just tasty food.” Mike Siegel said. ”I always joke and say —10 pounds of flavor in a five-pound sack. There you go. On every plate. Just a little upscale food that tastes better. And we’ll keep doing everything we can from scratch.”

The Siegels hope Legends is their last and lasting contribution to the area food scene that began at the 24-hour Country Kitchen back in the 90s, through to Mike’s stint at the Pavilion Bar & Grill and at the then-Swiftel Center where Mike ran the kitchen and to modern day when both Mike and Sheana worked at Craft. They started Midwest Fresh as a catering and food truck operation in 2017 and have supplied food for Daktronics as well as weddings and events ever since.

Legends also features a walk-up window for the summer months, where kids from the Volga pool can come get an ice cream cone or folks out and about can stop in for a treat.

It’s all part of the vision of becoming a neighborhood staple to serve the people of Volga — and all the surrounding area.

“So far, our clientele has been a mixture of everybody, and that’s so nice,” Sheana Siegel said. “We get the high schoolers that come in; they have open campus, and we have a special just for them that’s really good deal, and a lot of them come in at least two or three times a week. And we have the older customers coming in, and some of them I remember from Country Kitchen. There were at least four or five from the nursing home today that I got to talk to for a while, and then we’re getting some business people in here. We’re getting the farmers. We’re getting the red hat ladies. We’re just getting a nice mixture of everybody. We really love it when the people who remember the building stop in.”

The Siegels are in the process of starting to staff up the diner for dinner service, but for now are open Tuesday through Friday for lunch.

“We’re really looking forward to getting expanded hours. But we just want to make sure we can do it right,” Mike Siegel said. “But mostly, it’s just fun to be here and we just have a place where people just come out and get a good meal and maybe feel nostalgic and get taken care of.”

Linehan is the Beacon’s managing editor and welcomes story tips and comments at BrookingsBeacon@gmail.com